Customized power solutions for industries such as electric utilities, new energy, and industrial manufacturing.
Low-Cost High-Efficiency Upgrade & Retrofit Solution for Industrial Earthing Transformers
1. Background and Global Pain Points
In numerous industrial plants worldwide with earthing transformers in operation for over 15 years, the equipment commonly faces the following challenges:
- Equipment Aging: Insulating oil degradation, multi-point earthing of iron cores, local overheating of windings, leading to increased failure rates.
- Low Energy Efficiency: No-load and load losses exceed the efficiency benchmarks specified in IEC 60076-1 / IEC 61869, resulting in high long-term electricity costs.
- Inadequate Protection: Lack of zero-sequence current monitoring and automatic compensation; arc extinction of single-phase earth faults is difficult, which may easily escalate into phase-to-phase short circuits.
- High Retrofit Difficulty: Full replacement requires huge investment and long power outage duration, seriously disrupting production schedules.
Full replacement not only incurs substantial capital expenditure but also may cause production shutdowns for several days. Therefore, a low-cost, rapid-implementation and high-efficiency upgrade path is urgently needed.
2. Overall Approach
Adopt a three-step progressive retrofit model:
- Diagnostic Assessment: Conduct comprehensive tests on existing earthing transformers, including insulation performance, temperature rise, loss measurement and earthing system detection, to formulate a retrofit priority list.
- Minimally Invasive Retrofit: Retain the main structure and iron core, install intelligent monitoring modules, optimize earthing methods, and replace high-loss components (e.g., windings, coolers).
- Phased Upgrade: First address safety hazards and energy efficiency shortcomings; then gradually introduce an intelligent operation and maintenance platform according to budgetary constraints, avoiding one-time large-scale investment.
This solution can reduce investment costs by 50%–70%, control power outage duration within 8–24 hours, and comply with IEC / IEEE / ISO international standards.
3. Implementation Path
| Step | Content | Methods & Tools | Expected Outcomes |
|---|---|---|---|
| ① Diagnostic Assessment | Insulating oil chromatography analysis, winding DC resistance test, no-load/load loss test, zero-sequence impedance measurement | Portable oil chromatograph, infrared thermal imager, variable-frequency power analyzer | Identify degraded components and retrofit priorities; formulate targeted solutions |
| ② Minimally Invasive Retrofit | - Replace with low-loss silicon steel sheets or partially rewind windings
|
Factory prefabricated modules, quick-disconnect joints | Reduce losses by 30%+; realize real-time monitoring of earth faults |
| ③ Phased Upgrade | - Phase 1: Meet safety and energy efficiency standards
|
Edge gateways, cloud platform integration (compliant with IEC 61850) | Gradually achieve intelligence; reduce O&M costs by an additional 20% |
4. Core Technologies (Compliant with International Standards)
4.1 Local Energy Efficiency Enhancement Technology
- Adopt high magnetic permeability cold-rolled silicon steel sheets (compliant with performance grades specified in IEC 60404-8-4), reducing no-load losses by 40%.
- Optimize winding conductor cross-section and transposition methods, cutting load losses by 20%–30%.
4.2 Intelligent Monitoring Installation Technology
- Install high-precision zero-sequence current transformers and temperature sensors at the neutral point and outlet side of the earthing transformer; upload data to the plant's SCADA system via edge gateways (in compliance with IEC 61850-8-1 / IEEE 802.3).
- Implement local threshold judgment and instant anomaly alarms to prevent fault escalation.
4.3 Earthing Method Optimization
- For systems with high capacitive current, install adjustable earthing resistors or small-sized arc suppression coils (compliant with IEEE 32) to achieve rapid arc extinction of single-phase earth faults (residual current ≤ 10 A).
- Adopt low-impedance earthing design to improve the reliability of relay protection operation.
4.4 Non-Stop Production/Short-Time Power Outage Construction Technology
- Utilize prefabricated modules and quick-disconnect joints, limiting single retrofit power outage duration to ≤ 24 h (referring to recommended practices in IEEE C57.12.00).
- Arrange key construction processes during plant shutdown or maintenance windows.
5. Functional and Performance Indicators
| Indicator | Before Retrofit | After Retrofit | Improvement Effect |
|---|---|---|---|
| No-Load Loss | 1.2% of rated capacity | ≤ 0.5% of rated capacity | Reduction rate ≥ 58% |
| Load Loss | Baseline value | ↓25% | Annual power saving of approximately 30,000–80,000 kWh (depending on capacity) |
| Single-Phase Earth Fault Arc Extinction Time | >300 ms (without compensation) | ≤ 150 ms (with compensation) | Fault escalation risk ↓80% |
| Investment Cost (vs. full replacement) | 100% | 30%–50% | Cost saving of 50%–70% |
| Power Outage Duration | Several days (full replacement) | 8–24 h | Minimize production impact |
6. Typical Global Case Study
10kV Earthing Transformer Retrofit Project for a Textile Mill (Europe, 18-year-old Equipment)
Problems: No-load losses exceeded the standard by 1.5 times; acetylene content in oil chromatography was close to the alarm threshold; no earth fault monitoring function.
Measures: Partially rewound the high-voltage windings + replaced with high-efficiency coolers; installed zero-sequence CTs and intelligent monitoring terminals; added a 20 A adjustable earthing resistor.
Results:
Measures: Partially rewound the high-voltage windings + replaced with high-efficiency coolers; installed zero-sequence CTs and intelligent monitoring terminals; added a 20 A adjustable earthing resistor.
Results:
- Reduced no-load losses to 0.45% of rated capacity, achieving annual power saving of 52,000 kWh.
- Realized real-time earth fault alarm, avoiding one production line trip caused by electric arcs.
- Total investment was only 38% of the full replacement solution, with the retrofit completed within a 16-hour power outage.
7. Benefit Analysis
- Economic Benefits: Cut equipment procurement and installation costs by 50%–70%; reduce annual operation electricity costs by 20%–30%.
- Safety Benefits: Eliminate insulation degradation and earthing hazards, complying with IEC 61936-1 (Electrical Installations for Power Systems) and IEEE C57 series standards.
- Sustainability Benefits: Phased upgrades avoid one-time financial pressure, and the intelligent O&M system can be gradually improved along with plant development.
- Environmental Benefits: Loss reduction directly cuts carbon emissions, achieving annual carbon reduction of approximately 30–80 tons (depending on capacity).
8. Internationally Applicable Standards
- IEC 60076-1: General Requirements for Power Transformers
- IEC 61869 series: Instrument Transformer Standards
- IEEE C57.12.00: General Requirements for Liquid-Immersed Distribution, Power and Regulating Transformers
- IEEE 32: Standard for Ground Fault Protection of Power Systems
- IEC 61850: Communication Networks and Systems for Power Utility Automation
- ISO 9001 / ISO 55001: Quality and Asset Management Systems, ensuring consistency and traceability of the retrofit process
Conclusion
Based on the principles of diagnosis-first, minimally invasive retrofit and phased upgrade, this solution realizes three-fold improvements in safety, energy efficiency and intelligence of earthing transformers in aging industrial plants without full equipment replacement, through local energy efficiency enhancement, intelligent monitoring installation and earthing method optimization. It meets international safety production and energy efficiency standards at the lowest cost, providing a replicable and scalable low-cost high-efficiency path for the retrofit of existing equipment in the global industrial sector.
Recent Solutions
